Home / Politics / Tribal Counsel

Tribal Counsel

Tribal CounselRemember the supermarket scene near the end of the Iraq War movie The Hurt Locker ? Jeremy Renner plays an Explosive Ordnance Disposal technician. After countless telephoto shots of IEDs going off terrifyingly close, the sergeant is finally safe at home in America with nothing more stressful to do than pick out which brand of cereal to buy his small family. But a fish-eye lens shot shows the valiant warrior lost in a supermarket aisle seemingly a mile long.

Vanity Fair war correspondent Sebastian Junger, codirector of the documentary Restrepo about American soldiers in Afghanistan, points out in his recent book Tribe: On Homecoming and Belonging that American soldiers currently suffer from the highest rate of post-traumatic stress disorder in human history.

This short book tries to sum up the political lessons Junger has learned from a quarter century of going to and coming home from dangerous places. It’s a work of swashbuckling anthropological theory that tries to answer the question raised by Restrepo: Why do the guys defending a fort in Afghanistan find living in a tiny bunker to be a blast, while coming home to America is so discombobulating for them?

Junger offers one original suggestion for how America should help veterans psychologically adjust. Drawing upon the traditions of tribal cultures where old warriors tell their stories around the fire, Junger suggests that everybody gather in their town hall on Veteran’s Day and listen to vets vent about their war experiences.

Junger organized the first such event in America in 2015 in his hometown of Marblehead, Mass., with Rep. Seth Moulton and soldier-strategist Andrew Bacevich. Don’t expect it to be a reassuring or even coherent experience, he warns. But the participants seem to get something out of it; and you owe it to them.

“As Junger laments, Americans today seem more interested in reviling one another than in cooperating.”

Junger’s focus in Tribe, however, lies less with what’s wrong with our ex-soldiers than with what’s wrong with the 21st-century American society they return to.

The author of The Perfect Storm is most famous as an adventure journalist, a rugged fellow who can persuade similarly manly if less articulate men to answer personal questions about what motivates them.

Junger starts Tribe with Benjamin Franklin’s curious 1753 observation that an Indian child raised in the white man’s ways would reliably give up modern conveniences after “one Indian ramble.” In contrast, whites ransomed from Indian kidnappers often pined away for tribal life.

Moreover, it was not uncommon for white men to voluntarily join Indian tribes, which is not something that happens much in these days of casinos and reservations. For example, the titanic Sam Houston spent a half-dozen years living with the Cherokee, first as a teenage runaway, later after resigning as governor of Tennessee when his first wife rejected him. Indian sojourns evidently helped him get over his depressions and set him on the way to becoming the first president of the Republic of Texas.

In Junger’s telling, the French philosophes’ concept of the Noble Savage was not wholly a fantasy, but European thinkers got the story backwards. Rather than living in solitude, according to Junger, tribe members benefit psychologically from community, unity, and equality.

In Junger’s rather sketchy description, tribal life sounds rather like being in the Army, although with less hierarchy, less marching, and even more gossip. Hunter-gatherers, the most intense form of tribal life, are strikingly egalitarian, constantly forming backbiting coalitions to undermine the confidence of superior hunters to keep the strongest men from monopolizing all the women.

Similarly, Junger notes, humans living under seemingly catastrophic conditions, such as London during the Blitz, his father’s hometown of Dresden under RAF raids, and the besieged Sarajevo he visited as a young reporter, seem to enjoy better overall mental health than peacetime Americans.

The American plague of rampage shootings, Junger observes, a bizarre modern phenomenon that seemed to emerge about a half century ago, stopped for a couple of years after 9/11, perhaps due to greater feelings of solidarity. A “community of suffering, a brotherhood of pain” tends to incline people to treat their neighbors better than times of prosperity and status competition.

Junger is particularly annoyed by how wealthy, peaceful, individualistic America puts up with so much self-dealing. He’s irritated by welfare fraud and appalled that virtually no financial titans went to jail for 2008. A self-respecting hunter-gatherer tribe, he thunders, wouldn’t put up with that kind of corruption. The previous administration’s refusal to prosecute any zillionaires “shows how completely de-tribalized the country has become,” Junger complains in a novel use of the word.

Most of Junger’s descriptions of the merits of tribal life are drawn from American Indian lore rather than from Muslim Afghanistan, even though he has spent much time there embedded with the U.S. Army. In Restrepo, local tribal life looks small-minded and deadening. The go-getting American officer tries to arrange win-win deals with the villagers, but the henna-bearded elders refuse to consider them.

The Pathans of Afghanistan and Pakistan may not be fair representatives of barbarian mores, though. They are a bitterly individualist and cutthroat culture, with proverbs that tend toward the horrifying:

One’s own mother and sister are disgusting.

When the floodwaters reach your chin, put your son beneath your feet.

In Winston Churchill’s description of his enemies in a punitive raid in 1897, however, Pathan tribal life at least seems entertaining:

Every family cultivates its vendetta; every clan, its feud. The numerous tribes and combinations of tribes all have their accounts to settle with one another. Nothing is ever forgotten, and very few debts are left unpaid…. The life of the Pathan is thus full of interest…

Churchill’s observation raises the key conceptual problem that Junger doesn’t really have any solution for: scale. While Junger uses the term “tribalism” to connote solidarity, which he desires for America, it more conventionally implies divisiveness along clan lines.

Yet both suggestions are useful. For instance, part of the appeal of American Indian life was that tribe members had the options of not just loyalty or voice, but also of exit. Tribes frequently fractured when different factions couldn’t get along. Rather than stay together and stab each other in the back, one group would up and leave. This was easier to do during historical times, when Indian country wasn’t at its Malthusian limit of population because Old World diseases were reducing the population. Plus, Indians didn’t much mind dividing into warring tribes because they enjoyed war.

On the other hand, tribal fractiousness doomed the Indians to lose to the far more united Americans. Most of the famous Indians in history—such as Pontiac, Tecumseh, and Sitting Bull—were political geniuses who could somehow get a large number of braves to show up at one time on one battlefield to fight the whites. We honor their names today because this was so hard to do.

As Junger laments, Americans today seem more interested in reviling one another than in cooperating. Perhaps that’s not surprising: America is a huge country and, luckily, hasn’t had to come together much to win wars in recent generations.

Fortunately, we already have a system, bequeathed to us by the Founders, for how we can get along without getting in each other’s faces: federalism. It’s long been out of fashion, but we can live and let live as long as we don’t insist upon micromanaging the daily lives of other Americans in distant parts of the country.

The other requirement is that we have to forswear trying to defeat our fellow citizens by importing foreigners to vote for our party. That kind of election rigging is lethal to camaraderie.

  • Dr. Lonny Shavelson found that 70% of female heroin users had been sexually molested in childhood.

    That is a face of PTSD no one cares to look at.

    • Nemon

      Psychological trauma in childhood are able to change the brain structure as well as the epigenetics of a person for the rest of his life.